Cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk are mixed together in a bowl and beaten until smooth. Combine the pudding mix and the milk. Scrape the sides of the bowl as needed while beating for several minutes. All-purpose flour: The flour holds the cookie together and creates the foundation for your other dry and wet ingredients.

Historically, the name “Nilla” was originally registered as a trademark in the United States by Nabisco in 1899. They have a slightly softer texture than Nilla Wafers, but they still hold up well when used as a base for the dessert. They both have a similar texture, and they’re both made with flour, sugar, eggs, and other basic ingredients.

Vanilla extract:For optimal flavor, reach for pure vanilla instead of imitation. Even better, try homemade vanilla extract! Nilla Wafers contain mostly wheat flour, sugar, vegetable oil, and vanilla extract. They also have other ingredients like leavening, salt, and soy lecithin. Is there a recipe for homemade vanilla wafers? When it comes to incorporating your chosen substitute into the actual recipe, some adjustments may be necessary. For instance, if you’re using a more potent-flavored cookie, you might need to reduce the amount of salt or other seasonings. Be sure to taste and adjust accordingly. Ensure your eggs are at room temperature before adding them to your mix! If your eggs are too cold, your batter will look curdled. To fix it, use a hairdryer to warm the batter up. Incorporating more unusual ingredients can also be fun. For instance, try using Doritos as a substitute. This might sound strange, but using the chips amplifies the savory and tangy flavors alongside the sweetness of the banana pudding, creating a unique experience. To enhance this unconventional twist further, add shredded cheddar cheese to the mix. The combination of sweet, salty, and tangy flavors is sure to surprise and impress your taste buds.

This is a great solution for anybody who doesn’t want to spend the time and energy making homemade vanilla wafers. If you prefer a crispier substitute, consider Melba toast. Though it’s not as sweet as Nilla Wafers, it offers a satisfying crunch and can be found in most grocery stores. Simply add a touch of sweetness by dusting it with powdered sugar or layering it with a sweet spread. With these tips, you can confidently choose and use the best substitute for Nilla Wafers in any recipe that calls for this classic cookie. Gluten-Free and Vegan Substitutes

Watch The Recipe Video!

One alternative is using pretzels, which provide a crunchy, salty contrast to the sweet pudding. To create a Nilla-like experience, try opting for peanut butter pretzels. The combination of salty pretzels and creamy peanut butter will provide a delicious contrast to the banana pudding, while still offering a satisfying crunch. In most cases, you can use all-purpose flour with your chosen Nilla Wafer substitute. If the alternative requires a specific type of flour, adjust your recipe accordingly to maintain the desired consistency. You can assemble this Nilla Wafer banana pudding in a large serving dish (like the trifle bowl seen here) or multiple smaller dishes. Either way, the end result is impressive!